FC Cincinnati turned an early setback into a decisive playoff victory on Thursday, beating Orlando City SC 3–1 at Inter&Co Stadium behind two goals from Evander. Martín Ojeda put the hosts ahead in the 26th minute, but Evander’s 43rd-minute penalty and 49th-minute strike flipped the fixture before Samuel Gidi sealed the result in the 85th.
The victory sent Cincinnati through the MLS Eastern Conference wild-card round and ended Orlando’s postseason hopes, despite the home side finishing with more possession and a substantial advantage in attempts.
Evander changes the picture around halftime
Ojeda gave Orlando the breakthrough in the 26th minute, establishing a lead the hosts held until the closing stages of the first half. With a home playoff victory within reach, Orlando instead saw the balance shift just before the interval.
Evander converted from the penalty spot in the 43rd minute to bring Cincinnati level. The teams went into halftime at 1–1, leaving the visitors with a foothold after spending much of the opening period behind.
Just four minutes into the second half, Evander struck again. His 49th-minute goal completed the turnaround and put Cincinnati ahead for the first time, leaving Orlando chasing an equalizer for almost the entire second half.
Orlando’s volume meets Cincinnati’s efficiency
The final statistics underlined the hosts’ frustration. Orlando had 57.8 percent possession and attempted 27 shots to Cincinnati’s 10, yet both sides finished with eight efforts on target. The visitors made their smaller share of opportunities count, turning three of their attempts into goals.
Cincinnati also collected four second-half yellow cards, with Tom Barlow, Pavel Bucha, Obinna Nwobodo and José Andrés Martínez all booked. But Orlando could not find the goal that would have restored parity.
Instead, Gidi supplied the decisive late contribution in the 85th minute. His goal stretched Cincinnati’s advantage to 3–1 and left the hosts facing a two-goal deficit in the closing stages.
A ruthless away response
For Orlando, the evening turned on the goals conceded immediately before and after halftime. Ojeda’s opener had offered the ideal platform, but the hosts could not translate their greater possession and shot total into a second goal.
For Cincinnati, Evander’s brace defined the comeback and Gidi’s late finish secured it: three goals from 10 attempts, an away playoff win, and a place in the next round.





